Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Seriously, what is wrong with some people?

An incident happened tonight that has left me wondering why some people are so keen on their own unpleasant prejudices that they want to attribute them to me, too.

It started when the following, anonymous comment on this post came up for moderation:

Number one, was it necessary at all the mention Fashion Hayley in your post at all? And your little passive aggressive dig at Hayleys "dodgy photo" is nasty and sickening.
Also seems that by mentioning her name and site, you might have thought you could up your blog hits.

Number two, get your facts right. The Top Shop dress wasn't designed for Incu. Incu are partners with Top Shop ("Incu Presents Top Shop) and sell Top Shop wares in their paddington store.

And this post on "sitting this one out" is stupid. To say that to consciously boycott a trend due to highly stylistic knowledge seems to be contradictory, sense trends and style are mutually exclusive.

You're just a ugly bitch who looks fucking disgusting in everything.
I was like, "Whoa! Whoa!" I was totally not about to approve that. But underneath the childishness, the aggression, and that final line – which is uglier, bitchier, and more fucking disgusting than anything I've ever written – I sensed that someone felt I was dissing Fashion Hayley.

Now, where would they have got that idea from? So I did a bit of digging in my blog stats, and noticed multiple Google searches for terms such as "Mel Campbell 'Fashion' Hayley" and "Footpath Zeitgeist fashion hayley".

Clearly someone was trying to find references that linked me and this blog to Fashion Hayley. I did the same search myself, and found this sorry piece of shit. The blogger's name is Luke Devine. The reason why my hate-commenter had to Google me tonight is that Devine did not link his post back here.

Perhaps he also didn't want me to discover (via my stats) what he'd written. Perhaps he didn't want to give me a chance to respond to the way he has blatantly twisted my comments to attribute opinions to me that I simply do not hold.

Usually I have better things to do on the internet than feed trolls – for instance, looking at pictures of cats or playing Flash games – but the fact that Devine has tagged his post with my full name, and is sending hate comments my way, means that I feel compelled to respond. So I posted the following on his blog as a comment…

Luke, you have utterly misrepresented me. I don't share your weird dislike for Hayley Hughes or belittle any of her successes. I am not trying to make her "look kind of stupid" – rather, I'd suggest YOU want her to look stupid, so you're pinning those opinions on me.

Hayley works hard and I respect her genuine enthusiasm for the fashion industry. I actually pity you for being so bitter and suspicious that you would read my blog post as "surreptitious female bitchiness" or "a backhanded piece of blatant cross promotion", and consider it only a "remote possibility" that I could be sincere.

I am a regular reader of Hayley's blog. (I wonder if you know what it's like to read blogs regularly, to get a sense for the writer's tone and favourite topics, rather than Google searching them as fodder for your snark.) So when I spotted that dress in Big W, I remembered that Hayley had bought one, and that it was similar to another dress she'd bought in Sydney.

The reason I apologised for reproducing the dodgy photo is that in the blog post where it originally appears – and which I CLEARLY linked to – Hayley herself writes: 'Photos of me on nights out are at best terrible. Believe it or not this is the least bad of the bunch."

So yeah – I WAS genuinely apologising, because I wanted to show Hayley wearing the dress, but the only image on her blog was this one that even she admits she didn't like. I included the other pic of Hayley in the similar Topshop dress… because she looks BETTER in that pic! Of course, you unkindly refer to her as "aping a fashion model". Jeez, we just can't win with you.

While I'm here, let me add that I don't see Footpath Zeitgeist as a 'fashion' blog – it's a research blog where I semi-regularly post my thoughts about bodies, clothes and pop culture. These concerns only sometimes overlap with the industrial operations of the fashion industry. I don't give a shit about the amount of site traffic it gets, about 'cross promotion', or about being part of some 'machine'.


Luke Devine said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Luke Devine said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Kai Jones said...

Poor Luke. You're just a lying internet troll. Classic patriarchy move, dismissing a woman's argument by calling it emotional.

Tracey said...

I find Luke's reference to including a mildly unflattering picture as an "...example of surreptitious female bitchiness" particularly nasty. What makes me feel sick is his misogyny and stereotyping.

I'm a regular reader of this blog and I remember reading the post in question when it first appeared. I certainly didn't read it as some kind of backhanded swipe at Hayley. Perhaps my ugly ladybrain malfunctioned that day?

I enjoy your work Mel, don't let the asshats get you down.

katie said...

Hayley is my friend and I'm sick of people trashing her. She is really smart and funny. People should look past her size because that isn't the main thing about her. Luke Devine is wrong, Hayley isn't unaware of her size or afraid to comment on sizism in the industry - anyone who reads her blog will know that she has addressed the issue time and time again.

Hayley is rising in the fashion industry and is basically unstoppable. Luke Devine how's your career going?

Mindy said...

Is Luke any relation to Miranda I wonder?

Thanks for the link to Fashion Hayley. She has a beautiful eye for photos and obviously loves fashion. It is women like her who have made buying clothes for women like me so much easier. I'm so glad she's going to work for City Ch*c. I'm really enjoying your blog too. (I wandered past from Larvatus Prodeo and have been happily reading ever since.)

Luke Devine said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mel said...

Jeez, I thought this was over now.

But anyway: Luke, if you are going to use phrases such as "Are you chicks that dumb?" then I don't think you can complain about being called a misogynist.